“Camp Nine” by Vivienne R. Schiffer

Title: Camp Nine
Author: Vivienne R. Schiffer
ISBN: 9781557289728
Pages: 198
Release date: October 2011
Publisher: University of Arkansas Press
Genre: Historical fiction
Format: ARC (Hardcover)
Source: TLC Book Tours
Rating: 4 out of 5

Cecilia Morton—“Chess,” as everyone calls her—is an average, gangly girl growing up in the 1940s Arkansas Delta. When her father died a few years ago, she became heir to his land and the massive holdings of his father as well. But her grandfather is not ready to relinquish control yet, and when he sells off some of Chess’s father’s land to the US government to build a Japanese American detainment camp, he sets in motion events that no one in their small town could have fathomed.

Soon, the detainees arrive—mostly from California—and settle into their new, heavily circumscribed lives. But their presence stirs unease within the rural town, particularly among members of the local Ku Klux Klan.

Chess’s mother, Carolina Morton, is a little different than the other mothers in Rook, Arkansas. A first-generation American, Carrie was born of immigrant Italian parents and raised by a local African American woman. With such a multicultural upbringing and unique not-quite-inside-but-not-quite-outside perspective, Carrie sympathizes with the outsiders and vows to help them.

Carrie befriends the Matsuis, an attractive couple with two dashing sons, and Carrie drags her daughter to the camp until Chess feels a sense of belonging there. No one talks about books the way that Henry Matsui does with her, and no one plays the guitar like young David Matsui. As the Matsuis struggle to adjust in the camp, Henry and David confront what it is to be American, and their exploration of identity leaves an indelible mark on Chess. Decades later, she reflects:

I knew that Camp Nine was something that should never have been. It destroyed lives and separated families; it interrupted joys and brought, in their stead, wretched sorrows. But the experience was mine, too. On a deeper level than I had ever understood, Camp Nine had defined my life.

The contrast of these well-dressed and brilliant urbanites against the sweltering heat and suffocating dust of the Delta is an image I haven’t seen explored in the (admittedly few) books I have read about Japanese American detainees during the war. Schiffer paints vivid images of the Delta, and her portrayal of the vast chasms within its society in the forties is fantastic, such as when she is explaining why the KKK was almost exclusively appealing to lower-class men:

Comprising the lowest form of white society, the new Klan represented the poor man’s answer to all his problems. Its real aim was to ensure the survival, by any means possible, of his endangered niche in our world—one step above the black man.

One of the story’s main conflicts revolves around two questions asked of the detainees—trick questions, really, to prove beyond doubt that the prisoners renounced any ties with Japan and were willing to serve the United States’ government. When Chess asks Mr. Hayashida, an old, quiet farmer at Camp Nine, about why the questions are so important, he replies, “The world would be a better place if the government stopped asking questions of the people, and the people started asking questions of the government.” The question of loyalty is central to understanding the strain placed upon families of suspect origin in the US.

In addition to exploring relationships between and among the detainees, the book does a good job relating Chess’s history—her Italian mother, her whitebread grandfather—to her future. Schiffer expertly teases out various themes of family and history in a world where little is forgotten.

However, the best parts of the book are when characters break from tradition: David becomes a world-class blues musician; Carrie embarks upon an affair with a married man that attracts little retribution; and Chess, instead of leaving the ugliness of Camp Nine far behind her, reclaims the land that her grandfather sold and tends to it lovingly.

Don’t just take my word for it! Buy Camp Nine for yourself from an independent bookstore. Each sale from this link helps support Melody & Words.

And check out what other reviewers on the tour have been saying:

October 31: Broken Teepee
November 2: Literature and a Lens
November 3: Wordsmithonia
November 7: Booksie’s Blog
November 8: Lit and Life
November 9: Write Meg!
November 10: Juggling Life
November 11: Picky Girl
November 14: BookNAround
November 15: Savvy Verse and Wit
November 16: Books Like Breathing
November 17: A Bookish Affair
November 21: For the Love of Books
November 22: Buried in Print
November 23: The Lost Entwife
November 28: In the Next Room
November 29: Diary of an Eccentric
December 1: The Adventures of an Intrepid Reader

6 replies »

  1. Ooh yes, people asking questions of the government would definitely have been a step in the right direction.

    This sounds like an amazing read – I’m so glad you enjoyed it! Thanks for being a part of the tour.


  2. Your comment about loyalty made me think, too, of the difficulty that Chass has near the end of the novel, trying to decide what to do with the knowledge that she has: who does she tell, who does she trust. It’s interesting how the theme folds over like that!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 207 other subscribers

NBCC Member

%d bloggers like this: