“The Heroes” by Joe Abercrombie

Title: The Heroes
Author: Joe Abercrombie
ISBN: 9780316044981
Pages: 560
Release date: February 2011
Publisher: Orbit
Genre: Fantasy
Formats: Hardcover
Sources: Personal collection
Rating: 4 out of 5


Joe Abercrombie’s new fantasy novel The Heroes continues in the world set in The First Law Trilogy. This time, he takes us to a single battle fought between the comparatively modern Union and the barbarians of the North. The story is told from the perspective of three Union and three Northern characters who all fight in the battle one way or another. Like Abercrombie’s previous novel, Best Served Cold, a few familiar faces from the first trilogy appear.

They fight over a steep hill called the Heroes, ringed with stones at the top to memorialize dead warriors of the past. As the battle progresses, all the characters contemplate the need for bravery in battle, what a hero truly is, and whether that is anything they would want to be.


The book is in many ways a send-up of war novels as a whole, where the overall context of the battle is never explained because the reader presumably already knows how these two armies came to be facing one another. While the reader is given only vague hints about the historical context of this confrontation, it truly doesn’t matter much to the characters involved. All that is important is the fighting that must be done.

Abercrombie in many ways returns to his bread and butter when he describes the action between these two contrasting sides. In comparison, Best Served Cold followed the action of several battles in the far-off continent of Styria, which was not fleshed out very well. Often the reader had to provide his own idea of what sort of place it was and what sort of people lived there (I found myself imagining Italy before the Renaissance).

The Heroes does not make this mistake. Instead, it is set in the frozen North, a place much easier to imagine and already well established in the previous First Law Trilogy. The two sides are easily distinguishable and, as a reader, you are free to pick whichever side you hope prevails.

Abercrombie seems in his element in a war novel setting, unafraid to introduce military jargon to describe the movements of divisions and regiments while still capable of maintaining a human perspective in the struggles involved. The book focuses on a very short time period (all but the final chapter of the book takes place over only five days) and one specific locale around the Northern town of Osrung.

This is a surprisingly unusual approach in fantasy, where sweeping scale is so often a key element in storytelling. But considering that this is a self-contained novel, having a comparatively tight story is effective and essential, and another element that made this installment superior to Best Served Cold.

3 replies »

  1. I loved Abercrombie’s First Law series. they were a fantasy game changer for me. But the battle scenes in those books didn’t do much for me, I’m just not into battle scenes and military jargon and such. I’m also a little worried The Heroes is a little too bloody and violent, even for my tastes. I’ll read this eventually, I promise, I might just wait a while.


    • Well, the book does have some battle scenes and military jargon. It is, after all, about a battle. But it didn’t strike me as any more violent than Best Served Cold. To each his/her own, but if you like Abercrombie, I wouldn’t avoid this one for that reason. At least there isn’t any torture this time.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 207 other subscribers

NBCC Member

%d bloggers like this: